We Share Our Take on the Ongoing Cork Versus Cap Debate...

Published: 13/06/2018
Author: Anja Bekker, Head of Marketing & Distribution
  • DE-TOREN-BLOG-IMAGES-06

We Share Our Take on the Ongoing Cork Versus Cap Debate...

Published: 13/06/2018
Author: Anja Bekker, Head of Marketing & Distribution

Since the very first introduction of screw caps, the much debated cork vs cap subject has been one of much controversy in the wine industry and a hot topic amongst wine lovers too. Though both methods have its pros & cons (as needed for any good debate, otherwise there wouldn't be one in the first place), we did a little digging of our own, in search of the most recent research's findings on this matter...

Wine traditionalists have long looked down on screw top bottles, but understand one thing, we certainly don't. There is undoubtedly a time and place for it, otherwise it wouldn't have been around since 1964. The wine modernists on the other hand, claim that there are more advantages to the use of the nifty little screw cap, including its ease of opening, the prevention of oxidation and tainted wine... And maybe that's true, but you have to agree, the sound of metal screeching definitely sends all the romance out the door!

The humble cork has been around since the 1400s and has stood the test of time in proving its capability to preserve wine for long periods of time. Some experts are of the opinion that the slow ingress of oxygen through the porous cork is critical in the process of aging wine. Other experts in the field believe that this exact element is what causes wines to be tainted. We have all opened a bottle that is tainted or corked, the common term used to refer to the presence of a chemical compound called TCA (trichloroanisole), which is formed when a natural fungi (of which many reside in the cork) comes in contact with certain elements within the wine. This gives the wine a mouldy smell or wet cardboard taste. The screwcap on the other side, are believed to cause a process of reduction, leading to a sulphur smell which can alter the taste of wines. It essentially depends on the sacrifice you are willing to make for something that is VERY rewarding!

Certain wines, especially the big, bold cultivars such as Cabernet Sauvignon, benefits greatly from a few years' aging to ensure a silky, elegant wine and we are still of the belief that cork is best for this natural process, allowing the admission of the required oxygen. The screwcap only gained popularity in the 1980s due to a period of poor cork quality which left many bottles undrinkable. So the heated debates date back to that era and have resulted in the publishing of one list after the other, comparing the pros and cons of these two wine sealing methods. The benefits of the screwcap include its affordability, the ease of opening, the elimination of tainted wine, whereas its disadvantages include the variable manufacturing quality, its non-biodegradable factor, the association with 'cheap' wines and no allowance for the wine to breathe. Corks on the other hand, are seen as a natural renewable resource, it's historically preferred, it allows the wine to breathe and have a proven record of long-term wine aging. The downside according to studies is the element of tainted wine, it is more expensive than the cork alternatives and it varies in quality, leading to inconsistent ingression of oxygen.

Due to these years and years of controversial opinions, the Oregon State University (in 2004) and the University of Oxford (in 2017), both conducted a study to investigate the matter, in the hope to settle this matter once and for all. In both studies, during a blind taste test, it was found that consumers can't really tell the difference between a cork and a screwcap wine. However, when asked to choose the best between the two bottles of wine, while the bottles are revealed, majority chose the wine bottle sealed with a cork. The consumers' reasoning behind this was the perception of superior quality associated with a cork sealed bottle of wine. The University of Oxford even went as far as making use of brain scanning technology to test how a person's emotions are affected by the sounds, aromas and sensations associated with opening a bottle of wine sealed with a cork versus cap. The conclusive result was an average rating of 15% higher for cork-sealed wines than the cap-sealed wines.

So is it maybe after all just our brains holding our taste senses captive? But then again, isn't that the whole point of the human's multi-sensory capabilities? The unique creak and pop of a wine cork evoke emotions of enjoyment, celebration, relaxation and intimacy. The crack and twist of a screw top doesn't really do the same, does it? In our humble opinion, the screwcap won't ever be able to match the sensation experienced with pulling a cork!

So, the modernists will always be able to give you a 1000 reasons why the screw cap is better than the cork (including its ease of opening, I mean really?!) whilst the traditionalists will be able to do the very same thing for the cork. There is thus really no wrong or right answer - it comes down to preference, research confirms that, and we sure know what we prefer. For as long as possible, De Toren would like to retain the romance...

 

Read more here on the 2016 vintage release of the prestigious Book XVII...

We spend some time with a top Dutch sommelier, Ronald Opten...

We reveal some stellar reviews, as De Toren is found amongst SA's finest...

Exclusive Interview with Top Dutch Sommelier, Lukas Wiegman...

Notice: Undefined index: categories in /usr/www/users/detorvqyfe/cache/smarty/compile/a5/54/11/a55411a06eaf0638e4b15e016e42d7489549502c.file.news.tpl.php on line 236

We chat to Lukas Wiegman, a top Dutch sommelier, who is very familiar with De Toren, especially after having spent the recent 2019 harvest with us on the estate, as part of our annual harvest team. The former sommelier of FG Restaurant, a Michelin two-star restaurant situated in Rotterdam, tells...

Bigger, Better, Best When Cellaring Wine...

Notice: Undefined index: categories in /usr/www/users/detorvqyfe/cache/smarty/compile/a5/54/11/a55411a06eaf0638e4b15e016e42d7489549502c.file.news.tpl.php on line 236

Size definitely matters, especially when it comes to the world of wine - bigger often means better. Apart from the fact that it implies 'celebration', there is actual science behind the thought that enjoying wine from a larger wine bottle produces a better taste. But why? We did a bit of digging...

Get to know the Formidable Taryn Nortje...

Notice: Undefined index: categories in /usr/www/users/detorvqyfe/cache/smarty/compile/a5/54/11/a55411a06eaf0638e4b15e016e42d7489549502c.file.news.tpl.php on line 236

One of South Africa's most exciting sommeliers, Taryn Nortjé, from the esteemed Pretoria-based, Restaurant Mosaic at The Orient Hotel, chats to us about all things wine. Well recognized as one of South Africa's top sommeliers today, Taryn shares her journey into the world of wine with us....

Exclusive Interview with SA Master of Wine, Greg Sherwood...

Notice: Undefined index: categories in /usr/www/users/detorvqyfe/cache/smarty/compile/a5/54/11/a55411a06eaf0638e4b15e016e42d7489549502c.file.news.tpl.php on line 236

In this interview we chat to Greg Sherwood, eminent London-based South African Master of Wine and Senior Fine Wine Buyer for Handford Wines. Best known for his wealth of knowledge and experience in the industry, Greg shares more about himself, his journey and the beautiful world of wine....

We get to know Mike Buthelezi, Top SA Sommelier...

Notice: Undefined index: categories in /usr/www/users/detorvqyfe/cache/smarty/compile/a5/54/11/a55411a06eaf0638e4b15e016e42d7489549502c.file.news.tpl.php on line 236

In this interview, we chat to Mike Buthelezi, Sommelier of Sandton's esteemed Epicure Restaurant, well recognized as one of South Africa's top culinary experiences. Having had the opportunity to work in various dimensions of SA's hospitality industry and regarded as one of SA's leading...

No One Glass to Rule Them All...

Notice: Undefined index: categories in /usr/www/users/detorvqyfe/cache/smarty/compile/a5/54/11/a55411a06eaf0638e4b15e016e42d7489549502c.file.news.tpl.php on line 236

There is nothing better than being served (a great) wine in a great glass - it truly gladdens the heart of a wine enthusiast! A top wine is obviously fantastic in any glass of any shape or size, no one is disputing that, but isn't it just all the more enjoyable when served in the perfect...

We Share Our Take on the Ongoing Cork Versus Cap Debate...

Notice: Undefined index: categories in /usr/www/users/detorvqyfe/cache/smarty/compile/a5/54/11/a55411a06eaf0638e4b15e016e42d7489549502c.file.news.tpl.php on line 236

Since the very first introduction of screw caps, the much debated cork vs cap subject has been one of much controversy in the wine industry and a hot topic amongst wine lovers too. Though both methods have its pros & cons (as needed for any good debate, otherwise there wouldn't be one in the...

Exclusive Interview with Top Netherlands Sommelier, Ronald Opten...

Notice: Undefined index: categories in /usr/www/users/detorvqyfe/cache/smarty/compile/a5/54/11/a55411a06eaf0638e4b15e016e42d7489549502c.file.news.tpl.php on line 236

We chat to the Master Sommelier of the luxurious Amstel Hotel's La Rive Restaurant, well recognised as one of Netherland's top culinary experiences. Best known for his wealth of experience and regarded as a leading Maitre d'-Sommelier, Ronald shares his story with us... Before you relocated...

Exclusive Interview with Top SA Sommelier, Lloyd Jusa...

Notice: Undefined index: categories in /usr/www/users/detorvqyfe/cache/smarty/compile/a5/54/11/a55411a06eaf0638e4b15e016e42d7489549502c.file.news.tpl.php on line 236

In this interview, we chat to Lloyd Jusa, Head Sommelier of Johannesburg’s luxurious Saxon Hotel, Villas and Spa, well recognized as one of South Africa’s top hospitality and culinary experiences. Best known for his wealth of knowledge and regarded as one of SA’s leading...

SA's Best Young Sommelier, Wikus Human

Notice: Undefined index: categories in /usr/www/users/detorvqyfe/cache/smarty/compile/a5/54/11/a55411a06eaf0638e4b15e016e42d7489549502c.file.news.tpl.php on line 236

In this interview, we chat to Wikus Human, the Head Sommelier of Marble Restaurant, situated in the heart of Johannesburg, well recognized as one of South Africa’s top restaurants. Best known for his recent achievement as winner of the South Africa’s Best young Sommelier’...

The Art of Decanting

Notice: Undefined index: categories in /usr/www/users/detorvqyfe/cache/smarty/compile/a5/54/11/a55411a06eaf0638e4b15e016e42d7489549502c.file.news.tpl.php on line 236

The season of festive celebrations, blissful parties, extravagant lunches and jovial dinners is upon us, and what better way to spoil yourself and your guests with the ultimate culinary feast and a beautiful array of wines, decanted of course… We know all too well that during the silly...

Exclusive interview with top Dutch sommelier, Koen van der Plas

Notice: Undefined index: categories in /usr/www/users/detorvqyfe/cache/smarty/compile/a5/54/11/a55411a06eaf0638e4b15e016e42d7489549502c.file.news.tpl.php on line 236

In this interview we chat to top Dutch sommelier, Koen van der Plas, better known as the head sommelier of Inter Scaldes, a two star Michelin restaurant in the Netherlands. In this article, Koen shares his passion for travelling, South African wines, exceptional food and wine pairings and his...

Pretoria, the first to taste the potential De Toren Z 2016 blends...

Notice: Undefined index: categories in /usr/www/users/detorvqyfe/cache/smarty/compile/a5/54/11/a55411a06eaf0638e4b15e016e42d7489549502c.file.news.tpl.php on line 236

A firm favourite for more than 20 years, situated in the heart of Pretoria, the newly opened Forti Grill & Bar was an absolute must for our first, annual De Toren Z Blend Tasting. The travel across Johannesburg to Pretoria, was well worth it, as the 9 blends on tasting was each...

A phenomenal venue & the 1st De Toren Fusion V 2016 Blend Tasting

Notice: Undefined index: categories in /usr/www/users/detorvqyfe/cache/smarty/compile/a5/54/11/a55411a06eaf0638e4b15e016e42d7489549502c.file.news.tpl.php on line 236

The Silo, a magical space towering above the V&A Waterfront with a 360˚ degree view! Surrounded by the natural wonder of South Africa’s Mother City, we hosted the very first De Toren Fusion V 2016 Vintage Blend Tasting at the spectacular Silo Hotel. It was an outstanding day,...

Panoramic views for the 2nd De Toren Fusion V 2016 Blend Tasting

Notice: Undefined index: categories in /usr/www/users/detorvqyfe/cache/smarty/compile/a5/54/11/a55411a06eaf0638e4b15e016e42d7489549502c.file.news.tpl.php on line 236

A day of appreciating the picturesque view and the signature experience of tapas for two at the renowned Chef’s Warehouse at Beau Constantia was an absolute delight. This, together with the enjoyment of an incredible selection of older De Toren Fusion V vintages, most definitely made...

De Toren Z 2016 Vintage Blend Tasting in the heart of the historic St James in London

Notice: Undefined index: categories in /usr/www/users/detorvqyfe/cache/smarty/compile/a5/54/11/a55411a06eaf0638e4b15e016e42d7489549502c.file.news.tpl.php on line 236

A private members’ club like no other, founded by wine lovers, for wine lovers. A home for the finest wines in the world, including the De Toren wines . It was only fitting to host the De Toren Z 2016 Blend Tastings here, in the classically elegant Lutyens Room, a private dining...

Available For Your Enjoyment Around The World

Notice: Undefined index: categories in /usr/www/users/detorvqyfe/cache/smarty/compile/a5/54/11/a55411a06eaf0638e4b15e016e42d7489549502c.file.news.tpl.php on line 236

In every quarterly newsletter we share stories and photos of restaurants and sommeliers from around the world with you. By now you might know that De Toren is available around the globe, but the question is, where exactly and how do you gain access to it. We thought it best to give you as much of...

Exclusive interview with Top South African Sommelier, Tinashe Nyamudoka...

Notice: Undefined index: categories in /usr/www/users/detorvqyfe/cache/smarty/compile/a5/54/11/a55411a06eaf0638e4b15e016e42d7489549502c.file.news.tpl.php on line 236

Better known as The Wine Whisperer ,  one of South Africa’s finest sommeliers and sommelier for the top South African restaurant, the Test Kitchen … Tinashe Nyamudoka, chats to De Toren about where his career started, his absolute favourite things about his job and what the...

Belgium Sommelier, Luk de Rooze, on where it all started...

Notice: Undefined index: categories in /usr/www/users/detorvqyfe/cache/smarty/compile/a5/54/11/a55411a06eaf0638e4b15e016e42d7489549502c.file.news.tpl.php on line 236

During his most recent trip to South Africa, we were fortunate enough meet with Luk de Rooze, the youngest sommelier to ever be bestowed the honorary title as 'Belgium's Best Sommelier', at De Toren. In this interview, he shares his passion for fine wine, especially South African wine, with us....

Balance, complexity, elegance and structure - what does it all mean?

Notice: Undefined index: categories in /usr/www/users/detorvqyfe/cache/smarty/compile/a5/54/11/a55411a06eaf0638e4b15e016e42d7489549502c.file.news.tpl.php on line 236

The world of wine is easily cluttered with lingo and terminology that complicates, confuse and distracts from the wine itself. Words such as balance, complexity, structure and elegance are commonly used, without further explanation or consideration. We are frequently asked about the use of these...

One of Brugge's hidden treasures...

Notice: Undefined index: categories in /usr/www/users/detorvqyfe/cache/smarty/compile/a5/54/11/a55411a06eaf0638e4b15e016e42d7489549502c.file.news.tpl.php on line 236

A trip to Brugges in Belgium simply requires a visit to the famous wine shop and wine bar, Blend , partly owned by sommelier Luk de Rooze ( read more here on our interview with Luk ). The concept behind Blend , is to give the people of Belgium and the tourists of course, the...

An infectious passion for people, food and wine...

Notice: Undefined index: categories in /usr/www/users/detorvqyfe/cache/smarty/compile/a5/54/11/a55411a06eaf0638e4b15e016e42d7489549502c.file.news.tpl.php on line 236

Another must-see in Belgium is Brasserie Grand Cru , a restaurant that shows true passion for wine and exciting culinary creations to accompany the great selection of fine wines. This is evident in the spectacular menu and wine list, offering a variety tailored to each and every occasion or...

At home with Belgium's wine master...

Notice: Undefined index: categories in /usr/www/users/detorvqyfe/cache/smarty/compile/a5/54/11/a55411a06eaf0638e4b15e016e42d7489549502c.file.news.tpl.php on line 236

The last stop of our winemaker, Charles's European trip was a fantastic day at Hans Fonck's wine shop, named Het Huis van De Wijnmeester . Hans is known as the wine master in Belgium and is a proud ambassador of South African wines, including the De Toren wine range . His wine shop is...

A Zambian piece of paradise...

Notice: Undefined index: categories in /usr/www/users/detorvqyfe/cache/smarty/compile/a5/54/11/a55411a06eaf0638e4b15e016e42d7489549502c.file.news.tpl.php on line 236

Planning that next holiday? What better place to consider than one of Zambia's most luxurious lodges? The Royal Chundu , winner of the 'World Travel Awards' for 6 consecutive years, a mere 30 kilometres from the magnificent Victoria Falls, definitely deserves a place on that bucket list....

Gareth Ferreira, South Africa's Best Sommelier, shares his journey and future plans

Notice: Undefined index: categories in /usr/www/users/detorvqyfe/cache/smarty/compile/a5/54/11/a55411a06eaf0638e4b15e016e42d7489549502c.file.news.tpl.php on line 236

Gareth Ferreira, the 'Best Sommelier in South Africa' and number 15 in the 'World's Best Sommelier' competition, shares his industry journey and plans for the future with us during an interview... Firstly, congratulations on your latest, outstanding achievement! Please share with us how it...

A one-of-a-kind wine club opens its doors in London

Notice: Undefined index: categories in /usr/www/users/detorvqyfe/cache/smarty/compile/a5/54/11/a55411a06eaf0638e4b15e016e42d7489549502c.file.news.tpl.php on line 236

In this newsletter, we chat to South Africa's Best Sommelier, Gareth Ferreira about his future endeavours. Part of these plans includes his work at 67 Pall Mall, London's first club ever for wine lovers. Read more here on the interview with Gareth Ferreira This club is in a league of...

South Africa's Top Restaurants

Notice: Undefined index: categories in /usr/www/users/detorvqyfe/cache/smarty/compile/a5/54/11/a55411a06eaf0638e4b15e016e42d7489549502c.file.news.tpl.php on line 236

With the South African Eat Out Mercedes-Benz Restaurant Awards this past month, it is only fitting to share in the celebration of the great accomplishment of some of our esteemed customers. The annual awards ceremony, hosted in South Africa's mother city, Cape Town, is a luxurious, annual...

Our Cellar Master's visit to the USA

Notice: Undefined index: categories in /usr/www/users/detorvqyfe/cache/smarty/compile/a5/54/11/a55411a06eaf0638e4b15e016e42d7489549502c.file.news.tpl.php on line 236

On a recent trip, our cellar master, Albie Koch, had the fantastic opportunity to visit one of America's favourite restaurants, The Capital Grille. An intimate vertical tasting of the renowned Fusion V was hosted to celebrate the end of a wonderful and successful trip. De Toren's award-winning...

The investment and collection of fine wines

Notice: Undefined index: categories in /usr/www/users/detorvqyfe/cache/smarty/compile/a5/54/11/a55411a06eaf0638e4b15e016e42d7489549502c.file.news.tpl.php on line 236

Investment in luxury wines, such as the exclusive De Toren wine range, is by no means a new sensation or a fad. Internationally, investment in luxury wines has been around for centuries. The formal trading of fine wines, as a valuable commodity to generate profits, became a more established...

Around The World With De Toren

Notice: Undefined index: categories in /usr/www/users/detorvqyfe/cache/smarty/compile/a5/54/11/a55411a06eaf0638e4b15e016e42d7489549502c.file.news.tpl.php on line 236

South African born chef Jan Hendrik van der Westhuizen is the first SA chef pictured above to receive the Michelin Star award for his restaurant, JAN in Nice, France. We are proud to have De Toren Fusion V on the list! Seafood is what Eddie V's is known for, but their specialty is excellence...